|""Open your eyes and look at what you did!" - Dexter, to Mike"|
He was a choir conductor who was a pedophile and murdered at least three young boys (seven in the novels).
He was the first person (not chronologically) to be killed by Dexter Morgan in both the novel series and the Showtime series.
Donovan was a man in his mid-40s with graying hair and a wide smile. He dressed in nice suits and drove a station wagon.
He appeared to be a friendly, upstanding citizen, while following his urges to rape and murder young boys. When confronted by Dexter with the dark truths of his behavior, Mike closed his eyes to avoid seeing the dead boys. Terrified, he begged for mercy.
Mike Donovan killed at least three young boys. He lived a double life as a choir conductor, and pastor, while having a wife and two daughters. He was also a pedophile, child rapist, and serial killer. His wife almost assuredly had no idea of her husband's dark secrets.
"Soon you'll be wrapped into a few... neatly wrapped Hefties and my own small corner of the world will be a neater, happier place... a better place." - Dexter to Mike Donovan
Donovan enters his car after a choir performance, not realizing that Dexter is waiting in the backseat. After Donovan starts the engine, Dexter chokes him with a garrote wire, and orders him to drive to a remote pump station, the location where Donovan had buried the bodies of three boys.
There, Dexter drags Donovan inside and forces him to look at his victims' bodies, Donovan pleads for his life and Dexter guesses that the children had also begged for their lives, which Donovan doesn't deny. He asks Dexter to understand, to which Dexter replies that he does, because he can't help himself either... but he has standards, and could never hurt a child. Then Dexter uses a syringe to sedate Donovan, and restrains him to a kill table. After taking a blood slide through a scalpel cut, Dexter kills him by cutting his neck with a reciprocating saw.
Later, Mrs. Donovan comes to the police station to ask about the investigation, and Dexter watches her from nearby. He reassures himself that he was careful in this kill, and didn't leave any traces behind. James Doakes, who despises Dexter, questions him about why he is looking at the distraught widow.
- "Dexter" (killed)
- "Sunshine and Frosty Swirl" (mentioned, through detail of the killer, not by name)
- Dexter: The Game (killed)
- "Hail Mary, full of grace, the Lord is..."
- "I couldn't help myself, I just couldn't... please you have to understand!"
Mike Donovan was responsible for the deaths of at least three young boys, The three boys' rotting bodies were dug up by Dexter, who then forced Mike to look at them.
- Corey Balanti (age 12)
- Tyler Kale (age 14)
- Joe Bigalow (age 13)
- In Dexter: The Game, he has a fourth victim, the earliest, which Dexter can find and dig up, but has no information on, as he knows only three of the missing boys.
- In the novel, Darkly Dreaming Dexter, he killed seven.