All in the Family - Chapter One is the first of six episodes in the third season of the Dexter Early Cuts series. It belongs to the All in the Family storyline, which is the main plot from season three of Dexter Early Cuts.
The chapter starts with Dexter sitting in a car, on a stalk. His thoughts reveal that he almost never thinks of himself as human, although he sometimes feels (almost) at home with them. Dexter remarks that New Year's Eve is a time when people follow their baser urges. Nearby, an unknown bearded man is shown slashing his own tongue. This same man watches as a mustached man picks up a prostitute and drives away. The bearded man immediately follows them. Upon arrival at a hotel, the bearded man puts on a mask. Although she struggles, he kills the prostitute by slashing her throat with a straight razor. The bearded man then encloses the seemingly dead john inside a bag and takes it with him. Unbeknownst to him, Dexter had followed them all to the hotel and watched the events unfold from the shadows.