Talk:Professor James Gellar/@comment-1405841-20111022215936/@comment-174.65.129.100-20111030220014

Yeah sorry guys, there are some valid points but it makes no sense. I think the id extention, or multipule personality disorder theory, if proved correct, would be a bad move on the part of the writers. Erin reacted when Gellar touched her...why would Gellar harm himself to 'teach' Travis a lesson...how is Gellar passing on previous knowledge unknown by Travis, i.e. the snakes...Gellar painting the picture... If in fact they are going a Fight Club delusion route, they aren't doing it very well, and, to what end? What is the connection? It just seems to be waaaay too much for this fledgling serial killer to do alone, for instance, the green house kill with the locusts. Let's say he did murder Gellar...why? And why take on his 'persona' as a means of conscience? If he did kill Gellar to take his endtimes philosophy to fruition, then what is the nescesity of his delusion? I seriously hope this thoery is incorrect, because i dislike the implications, and lack of support behind it. Just seems like really terrible writing/plot construction. This season is only 12 episodes long and there isn't much foreshadowing to really make it seemless, which is what this type of writing requires.